Expert Insights from Buda Law Group, Trusted Immigration Attorneys
As the new Trump administration continues to take shape, immigration attorneys and applicants alike are bracing for potential changes in the adjudication of EB-1A immigrant visa petitions. Given the administration’s historical stance on employment-based immigration, many expect heightened scrutiny, increased Requests for Evidence (RFEs), and a higher rate of denials. However, while these concerns are valid, it is important to take a nuanced view of the adjudication process.
RFEs and Denials – Perception vs. Reality
A common perception is that surges in RFEs and denials are directly attributable to high-level policy shifts or explicit changes in agency guidance. However, a closer examination of the adjudication process suggests that these trends are often cyclical and driven by the natural progression of personnel within the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The actions of individual adjudicators, rather than sweeping policy mandates, are more likely to affect the outcome of any given petition, and it is important to work with counsel who understands the process and knows how to overcome issues that arise in the course of adjudication.
The Important Role of USCIS Adjudicators
At USCIS service centers, the officers who adjudicate cases play a critical role in evaluating EB-1A petitions, which are designed for individuals of extraordinary ability. Unlike some other visa categories, EB-1A petitions require a subjective analysis of the applicant’s qualifications, evidence of achievement, and overall contribution to their field. The governing regulations in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) provide only very general guidance regarding the evidence needed to establish eligibility, with more detailed guidance given in the USCIS Policy Manual.
At first blush, the EB-1A evidentiary standard in the regulations may appear to be attainable only to Nobel Prize-level geniuses. Newly hired adjudicators, who often lack experience in handling complex petitions, often issue RFEs based on a more demanding standard of evidence than what the regulations actually require. This is not necessarily due to restrictive policy changes but rather because these adjudicators are still developing their understanding of how to assess evidence effectively. Over time, as they gain experience and confidence in their decision-making, examiners are less likely to issue unnecessary RFEs. Conversely, when experienced adjudicators move on to other positions and new ones are brought in, unjustified RFEs become more common and RFE rates are likely to spike again. This natural turnover within USCIS means that RFE trends are more cyclical than purely policy-driven.
The Effect of Policy Changes and High-Level Agency Guidance
While it has been observed that RFE rates rose when the first Trump administration implemented policies such as the “Buy American, Hire American” (BAHA) executive order, which encouraged stricter scrutiny of employment-based immigration petitions, the correlation between such policies and increased RFEs is not always direct. Many attorneys have observed that despite changes in administration, the fundamental adjudication standards remain largely intact. The Administrative Appeals Office (AAO), which reviews USCIS decisions, has not issued sweeping new interpretations that would mandate more restrictive adjudication of EB-1A cases.
In fact, regulatory amendments affecting EB-1A adjudications have been minimal. The eligibility criteria for EB-1A petitions remain unchanged, and while adjudicators have some discretionary power, they are bound by existing case law and precedent decisions. Therefore, the notion that every uptick in RFEs is a direct result of political influence overlooks the more organic factors at play within USCIS. While horror stories have certainly emerged of outrageous RFEs and denials issued during the first Trump administration, any practitioner who has worked in the field long enough has seen numerous similar examples in any given administration.
Strong Case Preparation – The Key to Success
Despite concerns about the impact of a new Trump administration, petitioners should focus on the practical aspects of preparing strong applications rather than fearing potential political shifts. Since RFEs tend to be driven by individual adjudicator experience levels, applicants can mitigate their chances of receiving an RFE by working with experienced immigration counsel to ensure that their documentation is as comprehensive as possible. Some best practices include:
- Providing Clear and Concise Evidence: Adjudicators, especially those new to the role, are more likely to issue RFEs when evidence is ambiguous or requires extensive interpretation. Clearly organizing evidence to directly map onto the EB-1 criteria can help prevent unnecessary scrutiny.
- Anticipating Potential Areas of Weakness: Common RFE triggers include insufficient documentation of sustained acclaim, inadequate evidence of the existence and impact of one’s original contributions to the field, and technical deficiencies such as the absence of certified translations of foreign language documents.
- Referencing Favorable Authorities: While adjudicators have some discretion, citing favorable AAO decisions and relevant sections of the CFR and USICS Policy Manual can help establish precedent and reduce the likelihood of RFEs
Should you receive an RFE despite having submitted the strongest possible case, experienced counsel can make all the difference in spotting erroneous interpretations of the law by inexperienced examiners and advising you on obtaining additional evidence to bolster your case.
As with RFEs, denial trends are also subject to fluctuation based on the experience levels and interpretations of individual adjudicators. While a return to stricter adjudications under Trump may lead to an increase in denials, it is important to recognize that most denials stem from inadequate or unclear evidence rather than an overt policy directive. Additionally, denials can often be overcome through motions to reconsider, appeals to the AAO, re-filing with stronger documentation or, in select cases, suing the government in federal court. Once again, working with experienced immigration counsel is the key to prevailing on appeal.
Conclusion – How to Maximize Your Chances of Success
The fear of heightened scrutiny under the new Trump administration is understandable, but it is crucial to recognize that RFE and denial trends are not solely dictated by high-level policy changes. Rather, they tend to follow a more cyclical pattern driven by the hiring, training, and turnover of USCIS adjudicators. To maximize you chances of success, you should:
1. Gather Your Evidence
Prepare a comprehensive resume or CV and gather evidence that documents your accomplishments in your field: awards, publications, articles about your work, memberships is professional associations, service as a judge or peer reviewer, high salary, speaking engagements, intellectual property, etc.
2. Maintain Your Network
Make a list and begin contacting professional associates who would be willing to sign a letter of reference detailing your contributions to your field.
3. Work with Qualified Counsel
Consult an attorney with specific experience in the preparation of EB-1A cases, as most general practice attorneys, and even many immigration attorneys, do not often handle these kind of cases and are not readily familiar with how to prepare and present the evidence.
The key to success lies in working with experienced immigration counsel in order to navigate potential hurdles effectively—regardless of the political climate. In the end, while government policies may shape the broad framework of adjudication, the day-to-day reality of USCIS decision-making is often far less influenced by sweeping mandates than many assume.
At Buda Law Group, we possess the expertise you need to present your case in the best light, and we welcome you to contact us to discuss any concerns you might have, and how we can help you put together the strongest possible case, whichever way political winds may blow.
Contact Buda Law Group Today
📍 Office in 1201 W Huntington Dr UNIT 209, Arcadia, CA 91007, United States
📞 Call for a confidential consultation at +1 626-714-7492
🌐 Visit us at https://www.budalawgroup.net/